
Whether you are currently in the maintenance or the weight loss phase, establishing goals can be motivational. This is an important step we may take many times during our journey. Let’s learn more about setting goal weights that can help us to move forward even when it feels like progress is slow.
For more on healthy goals, check my post on New Year’s resolutions: https://lindawbrowning.com/2022/12/29/be-part-of-the-9/
There are many different types of goals we can set – certainly a number on a scale is just one. You may be interested in body fat percentage, waist circumference, getting off of a medication, a special outfit you’d like to fit into, a set number of push-ups, the time you can hold in a plank position, a flexibility measurement like splits, a distance or speed that you can run…the list goes on! There are also goals that are harder to objectively measure, like keeping up with the children in your life or finding it easier to do physical work.
These are all very valuable, but it is also useful to have a goal weight or range mind too. It’s good to have flexibility here – as we’ve learned in other posts, weight and BMI are definitely imperfect measurements.
For more on issues with using BMI, please see https://lindawbrowning.com/2023/02/16/body-measurements-waist-to-hip-ratios/ , or weight at https://lindawbrowning.com/2023/03/05/what-is-skinny-fat/
Many studies have shown that setting goal or target weights results in greater weight loss. A one year study with 35,000 participants in the UK found that those setting higher percentage goals (over 10% of their current body weight) lost the most. This is surprising, as typical medical advice is to set a more achievable goal such as a 5 to 10% loss (1). The problem with a more extreme goal is that it may be very difficult to maintain it in the long term.
In a study conducted in rural Iowa, USA, it was discovered that the frequency of goal setting was associated with greater weight loss. It’s also important to note that setting specific diet and exercise goals was most effective (2). These goals are associated with greater self-monitoring and positive lifestyle change.
So if you’ve decided that it would be useful to set a weight goal, how do you determine what it should be? Start by talking with a medical provider. Ideally, they are most familiar with your health and can provide guidance for your goal setting. Another idea would be to meet with a registered dietitian or licensed athletic trainer who would be knowledgeable about the dietary or exercise portions of your plan.
What not to do? Pick an unrealistic goal and then be unwilling to change it as you move forward. Be flexible and willing to adapt.
“If you set a weight that is too unrealistic for your body, then you will never maintain it long-term, even if you reach it, and reaching it may even feel like torture because your body is not meant to live at the number,” according to Brigitte Zeitlinz, M.P.H., R.D., C.D.N. (3).
Maybe you have already reached your goal, or are considering relaxing your original plan a bit. Here are some signs that you have met your health goals, whether or not you’ve attained that arbitrary number on a scale:
- Medically you have become healthier, with improved blood pressure, blood test results, and resting heart rate (3).
- You feel healthy and have acceptable energy levels (3).
- You are able to maintain your weight without excessive dieting (3).
- You are content with how you look and feel (4).
- You follow a healthy lifestyle (4).
So there you have it! Although weight is not an ideal measure of fitness, it does have a role to play in maintaining our health. Consider how you are feeling, and then set or update your goals.
(1). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5111772/#__ffn_sectitle




















